Senin, 14 April 2014

Learning using CALL by Iine and Nia

Learning using CALL (Computer-assisted language learning) is quite good for developing our language skills. As the development of technology growing, more and more people use CALL to enrich their knowledge. However, there are some pros and cons about learning language using CALL. CALL supports development of cognitive abilities. Many websites provide free-tests as well as exercises to do such as TOIEC tests, grammar tests even phonology tests are also available. Nevertheless, if we use free websites, we will not get further explanations when we choose or write wrong answers in a certain test. It makes us not able to learn from the mistakes.  Yet, if the website allows us to get feedback, it will help a lot.
Using CALL is efficient and effective. We only need internet to access it. At once, we can get new knowledge and experience from around the world in seconds. Because there are many kinds of exercises available, we can choose any topic that helps us to gain our goal. For instance, we want to be a receptionist and we need to improve our ability in speaking as well as listening we can simply type in search engine to get an appropriate exercise.  But however it needs internet access therefore it can be expensive for some groups and not easily to be reached.

Many multimedia CALL software packages claim their high level of interactivity. According to us, interactivity means two ways of communication. Interactivity is applied in some programs such as online games. It lets people can participate more than crossing multiple choice. The users will participate by playing game. Even though some people think CALL software packages don’t truly happened in real interaction but it still make people feel like they interact directly with the program. Since the program gives respond to our activities, it can be called as truly interactivity. Moreover, the programs are progressively developed by human beings. Therefore we think, the technology of the programs is more interactive as human nature. Shortly, we don’t face something “die”.     

In some points, I also agree with the statement of Davies that says “There is a danger, however, of relying too much on the computer’s ability”. The statement can be true because the interaction that occurs with computer may not be long last as what we want. The first feedback can be true and relevant but we cannot hope further and deeper respond from the program. And if it happens, it can make people disappoint. In case of this situation, it can be danger for human’s psychology. Moreover, if somebody is too depend with the technology, it can be more dangerous. He cannot develop himself independently. For example, someone likes to translate a text with Google Translate. As well as we know in some points the result of the translation may be wrong and not accurate at all. It causes someone’s ability cannot develop. 

Davies points out that many designers of CALL-based programs were "more interested in control rather than guidance". We think this kind of statement is wrong because actually CALL-based programs were more interested in guidance rather than control. CALL-based programs guide us and help us to reach our goal. CALL allows learners to have non-sequential learning habit; they can decide on their own which skills to develop and which course to use, as well as the speed and level by their own needs. In fact, we have different style of learning, and an incompatible style will cause serious conflicts to us. Computer is flexible because it can provide an exciting “fast” drill for one student and “slow” for another. We have freedom of expression within certain bounds that programmers create, such as grammar, vocabulary, etc. We can also repeat the course that we want to master as many as we wish. According to Ikeda (1999) in KiliƧkaya (2007), drill-type CALL materials are suitable for repetitive practice, which enable us to learn concepts and key elements in a subject area. In conclusion, CALL doesn’t control us because we can choose by our own freely which skills to develop and which course to use. CALL also guides us to develop it.


"Technology is racing ahead of pedagogy and, unfortunately, often driving the pedagogy. Above all, there is a need for further research into how language students learn. We still know relatively little about the learning process, but what little we know is often disregarded by multimedia developers." ­– Davies. This statement somehow is true. Sometimes we find some CALL software that involve a high level of technology but provide little help to language learning or find some CALL software that involve simple technology but are really helpful to language learning. For example, games in English language about adventures or farming which involve a high level of technology, the games itself provide little help to language learning. These kind of games make us focus on the way we play or finish the games and don’t focus on language learning. But if we play scrabble which involve simple technology, it is really helpful to language learning. This game focus on our vocabulary development and not only the way we play or finish the game itself. In short, We have to sort some CALL software that we want to use.

0 komentar:

Posting Komentar